The Story of Our Brake Discs – an Incredible Ordeal

Berichte Nordamerika & Mexiko – Offroad Travelers

To understand the story, we have to go back in time. Shortly after setting off from San Francisco towards Lake Tahoe, we had another flat tyre. We changed the tyre on the hard shoulder of Interstate 580 heading east, in the middle of rush hour. You can’t choose when you get a flat! With the spare wheel fitted we drove to Manteca and decided to go to a garage the next morning to fix the broken tyre and perhaps fit new tyres straight away. Our mud-terrain tyres had now done 50,000 kilometres, which isn’t much for tyres. But the tread was unevenly worn, as we had mostly driven on paved roads with tyres meant for mud and unpaved tracks.

Die Geschichte unserer Bremsscheiben – eine unglaubliche Tortur

In the USA it’s not easy to find a garage that repairs tyres with inner tubes and split-ring rims. So we ended up at the big chain Les Schwab. There we got good advice and chose the Toyo Open Country tyres. The BF Goodrich All-Terrain is more expensive, has a delivery time and isn’t necessarily better. As we had to change all four tyres, we had the rims balanced at the same time. While the garage fitted the new tyres, we went for breakfast. A good hour later we were able to pick up Muggl again. On we went to Lake Tahoe. After a few kilometres we noticed that the brakes juddered when braking. Christoph suspected that this had to do with the tyre change. In Tahoe we drove to another Les Schwab branch and explained our problem. They turned us away; the shaking had nothing to do with the tyres but was due to the brakes.

We drove on to Yosemite National Park and then towards Los Angeles. The shaking was with us constantly. As long as the vehicle was cold it wasn’t bad, but when it warmed up it shook badly and you didn’t want to brake too hard. Shortly before Santa Barbara we had an appointment at a garage anyway. Werner, a German, had been recommended to us by Daniel, whom we had met at the Overland Expo in Flagstaff. North American diesel had badly clogged our injection pump, and we had already had a new one sent by our mechanics in Germany. Werner looked at the brake discs and found that they were badly worn. Damn! If we’d known, we’d have ordered new brake discs at the same time. Time was pressing, as our car insurance was about to expire and we had to leave the USA in a few days. The agency wouldn’t extend our policy, and a new six-month policy for 1,700 US dollars was out of the question. We decided to have the brake discs sent to Mexico. We had no idea yet how complicated that would get.

Die Geschichte unserer Bremsscheiben – eine unglaubliche Tortur – Foto 3

We asked the ADAC for support and wanted the discs sent to a cargo office at one of the five international airports in Baja California, where we could pick them up. For days, even weeks, we were in contact with the ADAC. They didn’t give us much encouragement, as it was difficult to send parcels to Mexico and get them through customs. We would need an international customs agent, and even that would be no guarantee. If Mexican customs didn’t accept the delivery, the goods might even be destroyed. We didn’t want to risk that, because it had already been difficult to get brake discs for our Iveco. They’re only produced sporadically and were sold out at the time. Our garage had removed a set from a used Iveco that had only done 5,000 kilometres and was practically as good as new.

The parcel was ready to ship and waiting at the ADAC for further instructions. In Mexico we met Yasmin and Stefan in their Toyota Land Cruiser (Zebra). We decided to travel Baja together so we could do more off-road driving. The area is sparsely populated, and if you break down you’d have to wait a long time for someone to come by. In Bahía de los Ángeles we came across an American community living in a small bay, where they had their holiday homes and were enjoying retirement. They invited us to camp there and use the internet to solve our problem. I could go into detail, but that would go beyond the scope. In short, we had the ADAC send the brake discs to San Diego, to a friend who came to visit a week later. That was the least complicated way, and we were allowed to stay in paradise all that time, where we snorkelled with whale sharks, used the kayaks and paddled with dolphins, giant turtles and sea lions. Everyone looked after us wonderfully, and we were often invited to dinner in the evening. In the end we were even allowed to use the workshop, where Christoph and Stefan changed the brake discs and pads themselves with the men’s help.

Die Geschichte unserer Bremsscheiben – eine unglaubliche Tortur – Foto 2

Finally it’s done. After two weeks we continue south with mixed feelings. 280 kilometres of gravel track along the Baja 1000 route take us to San Francisquito, where we spend the night, and then on to Guerrero Negro. The last 30 kilometres are paved. But when we brake for the first time, it still judders. So it isn’t the brake discs after all? Did something go wrong during fitting? We want to go into town to buy food and do laundry. The men leave the women at the laundry and look for a garage. But without any Spanish they quickly come back and fetch me. Surprise: a flat tyre! Again! When it rains, it pours. We’re out of luck. Fortunately there are lots of garages in Mexico, and they fix tyres routinely. Our system with inner tubes is impractical, but this time we picked up a rusty nail at the taco stand. The tyre is quickly repaired, and we ask them to check the brakes. Right wheel bearing broken, the mechanic finds. Luckily we have a spare part with us, and it’s changed immediately. The Mexicans work patiently and meticulously, which reassures us. After three hours it’s late afternoon and we haven’t done our shopping yet. We decide to spend the night outside Guerrero Negro at the old shipyard. Relieved that the problem is solved.

The next morning we do our shopping before moving on. Back on tarmac and at higher speed, it shakes when braking just like before. At a loss, we contact our garage in Germany and other travellers with the same Iveco, and even send a video. Everyone suspects the brake discs. Our mechanic thinks they might be sticking slightly; rust or dirt in between could be causing the rattling. In El Marasal we go to the next garage. Christoph and Stefan want to take the brakes apart and clean them thoroughly. I ask whether we can use a space and tools. The boss agrees. The mechanics are helpful, watch us and hand us tools. They suspect it could be the new brake discs. There’s someone in town who can skim them. The apprentice takes the discs to the metal workshop by bike. Five hours later everything is reassembled. Christoph goes for a test drive and comes back dejected. Still the same problem! A mechanic rides along and says it must be the brake discs. We’re in despair. Still dirt in the system? Is something else broken?

Die Geschichte unserer Bremsscheiben – eine unglaubliche Tortur – Foto 4

Christoph is still wondering whether something went wrong during the tyre change. But what? The problem has plagued us ever since. A stupid coincidence or the real reason? Everyone claims it’s the brake discs; we’ve checked everything else three times. No screws or bolts are broken, no bearings defective. The mechanics at the garage are at a loss. We discuss spare parts and repairs to find a solution. They suggest checking everything again tomorrow. What else can we do? The boss asks: “You were at a garage in Guerrero Negro yesterday?” “Yes,” I answer. “That was my brother’s,” he says. We’re known far and wide. We’re to come back at 8 am. In the evening we go to our camp outside town among the cacti and keep discussing. Stefan knows about cars, but even he has no explanation. Christoph insists that the tyre change is to blame, and we want to swap the tyres from front to back. But that fails because the Mexicans tightened the nuts so hard that Stefan breaks a wrench. So tomorrow morning at the garage! The next morning I explain that we’d like to swap the tyres. The mechanic isn’t surprised and gets going. I suggest to the boss that he talk on the phone with our mechanic in Germany, who also speaks Spanish. At some point it had all become too complicated for me, and my Spanish was no longer enough. After the tyre swap Christoph takes a long test drive, and the problem has disappeared! Everyone is so perplexed that nobody can say anything. The workshop foreman drives himself and confirms that everything is fine and the braking performance is right. What still isn’t running true are the rims. Christoph was right: the tyre change at Les Schwab had consequences. We had the rims balanced there, and it went wrong. What an ordeal – we need to digest that first!